WEST ALLENHURST, NJ

REAL ESTATE MARKET UPDATE IN West Allenhurst, NJ

When buying a home, local market data and realtor expertise make ALL the difference. We update the local market data quarterly here, so check back frequently. If there’s a town not listed here that you would like market data for, email homes@theconnollyagency.com or give us a call.

The date below was compiled from the Monmouth-West Allenhurst Multiple Listing Service (FLEX-MLS) and provides an overview of recent sales activity in West Allenhurst.

For a Comprehensive real estate market update in West Allenhurst ,NJ, contact our NJ Shore Real Estate experts at The Connolly Agency. We look forward to hearing from you. 732-361-0800.

First Half of 2026 Compared to 2025

West Allenhurst’s first half of 2026 market showed a dramatic shift toward higher-priced transactions, with a substantial increase in average and median sale prices despite slightly fewer sales.The average list price increased 153.8%, rising from approximately $1.04 million to $2.63 million.The average sale price increased from approximately $947,000 to $2.52 million. Average days on market increased from 69 days to 107 days, while cumulative days on market increased similarly, from 69 days to 108 days.The sale price-to-list price ratio increased from 91% to 95%.

2026 Q1

In Q1 2026, West Allenhurst saw sales of 1 single family home, with a sale price of $4,200,000. This sale sits well above 2025’s annual average of $1,189,023, reflecting the high-end nature of this single transaction rather than a broad market shift. The home sold at 94% of list price, in line with last year’s 94%. The home spent 237 days on market, significantly longer than 2025’s 70-day average and indicative of how long a unique, high-priced property can take to find the right buyer.

2025 Compared to 2024 Annual Market Update

In 2025 Single Family home sales were up 40% with 21 homes sold, and the average sales price was down 3% to $1,189,023. Homes were selling for 6 percent less than list price and were on the market for 70 days.

First Half of 2025 Compared to 2024

In the first half of 2025, 5 single family homes were sold, which was a decrease from 7 homes in the first half of 2024. The total sales volume for Single Family homes sold in West Allenhurst decreased by 36%. The average sale price was $947,199, a decrease of 10% from the first half of 2024. Homes were on the market for an average of 69 days and sold for 91% of the list price in the first half of 2025.

2024 Compared to 2023 Year End Market

In 2024, 15 single family homes were sold, which was an increase from 10 homes in 2023. The total sales volume for Single Family homes sold in West Allenhurst 2024 increased by 24%. The average sales price was $1,225,566, a decrease of 17% from 2023. Homes were on the market for an average of 72 days and sold for 94% of the list price in 2024.

Third Quarter 2024 Compared to 2023

For the first three quarters in 2024 there were 12 homes that sold in West Allenhurst. The average sales price was $1,180,916 which is an 15% decrease from 2023. The average days on market were 63 and homes sold for 95% of list price.

First Half 2024 Compared to 2023

For the first half in 2024 there were 9 homes that sold in West Allenhurst. The average sales price was $1,309,000 which is an 4% increase from 2023. The average days on
market were 52 and homes sold for 94% of list price.

First Quarter 2024 Compared to 2023

For the first quarter in 2024 there were 3 homes that sold in West Allenhurst. The average sales price was $1,125,666 which is an 11% increase from 2023. The average days on market were 26 and homes sold for 97% of list price.

2023 Vs 2022 Annual Market Update

In 2023, 10 single family homes were sold, which was a decrease from 14 homes in 2022. The total sales volume for sold Single Family homes in West Allenhurst in 2023 decreased by 24%. The average sales price was $1,482,875, which is an increase of 7% from 2022. The homes were on the market an average of 44 days and sold for 92% of the listing price.

2021 Vs 2022 Annual Market Update

In the year of 2022, 1 single homes sold in West Allenhurst, on par with 2021. The average sales price was $1,200,000, down 4% from 2021, and the average days on market were 4 vs 20 days in 2021. Homes sold for 126% of the listing price vs 100% in 2021. Overall, the real estate volume is $1,200,000 down 4% compared to last year.

2022 Vs 2021 Yearly End Market Update

In 2022, 10 single homes were sold, which was a decrease from 1 homes in 2021. The total sales volume for sold Single Family homes in West Allenhurst in 2022 decreased by 43%. The average sales price was $1,440,500, an increase of 26% from 2021. The homes were on the market an average of 11 days and sold for 94% of the listing price.

2022 vs 2021 Market Update

For more Market updates for Allenhurst Click here.